The New Product Playbook
AboutShare
Appendix6.5

Research: The “Giver” Mindset in Tech

The “Giver” Mindset in Tech: Linking Generosity to Profitability and Loyalty

Introduction

In business, a “giver” mindset refers to prioritizing value and service to others without expecting immediate returns. In practice, this often means investing in customer experience, community, or employees up front – trusting that loyalty and profits will follow in the long run. Many U.S.-based tech companies have embraced this ethos, leading to notable gains in customer loyalty and profitability. This report examines case studies of tech companies (and key individuals) that lead with generosity, the metrics they use to track loyalty (such as retention rates and Net Promoter Scores), and how this approach impacted their financial performance. We also consider research from Adam Grant’s Give and Take on how “givers” fare in business, and we analyze counterexamples where a value-first strategy failed (often due to unsustainable models or poor product fit). The emphasis throughout is on long-term profitability (not just revenue) driven by loyal customers.

Givers vs. Takers: What the Research Shows

Organizational psychologist Adam Grant defines givers as those who “contribute to others without seeking anything in return,” whereas takers try to claim as much value as possible for themselves. Interestingly, Grant’s research finds that givers are overrepresented at both ends of the success spectrum. In professional settings, selfless givers can sometimes be exploited and end up as the lowest performers. However, Grant also found that the top performers were often givers. In a sales study, the highest revenue generators had the highest giver scores – they earned 50% more annual revenue than average, outperforming both takers and matchers. Grant argues that successful givers find ways to help others effectively – they build broad goodwill and “spread success” in their organizations. Over time, takers often breed resentment and undermine culture.

Case Studies: Generosity Driving Growth in Tech

Amazon – Customer Obsession and Lifetime Loyalty

Amazon focused on customer satisfaction over short-term profit. Amazon Prime members have 93% retention after year one and 98% after year two. High satisfaction scores, including an 83/100 on the ACSI, drive massive repeat purchasing and strong lifetime value. This customer-centric strategy contributed to net income of ~$60B in 2022. Deloitte research supports this approach, showing customer-centric companies are 60% more profitable.

Zappos – Delivering Happiness and Repeat Business

Zappos’ legendary service – like ordering from competitors when out of stock – led to 75% of sales from repeat customers. They use Net Promoter Score (NPS) to measure satisfaction, consistently scoring highly (~57). This customer trust helped Zappos grow to $1B in revenue and be acquired by Amazon for $1.2B.

Google – “Focus on the User”

Google built loyalty by offering free, high-quality services like Gmail and Maps. This created habitual use and trust, fueling monetization through ads. Google has ~90% search market share, billions of loyal users, and Alphabet earned ~$60B net income in 2022.

Red Hat – Open Source and Profit

Red Hat gave away its Linux OS and sold support services. Over 90% of Fortune 500 companies use Red Hat, which became the first open-source company to exceed $1B in annual revenue. IBM acquired it for $34B.

More Examples

  • Netflix: Removed late fees, beating Blockbuster’s punitive model. Gained millions of loyal users. Cato Institute comparison.
  • HubSpot: Gave away tools and education, converting ~15% of users to paid. High NPS and free cash flow growth.
  • Satya Nadella at Microsoft: Fostered an empathetic, open culture. Open-sourced tech, embraced Linux. Microsoft stock rose 600%+.

Loyalty Metrics That Matter

  • Retention & Churn: e.g., Amazon Prime’s 93–98% retention.
  • NPS: Zappos uses it to drive service goals.
  • CSAT/ACSI: Amazon scores in the 80s.
  • Customer Lifetime Value (CLV): High with loyal customers.
  • Engagement: Time spent, DAUs, usage levels (e.g., Google search volume).

When Generosity Fails

Conclusion

Giver-minded companies like Amazon, Google, Red Hat, and Zappos show that prioritizing value for others often drives profit, loyalty, and resilience. When giving is strategic, measurable, and tied to a sound model, it becomes a major business advantage. The right kind of generosity – paired with good product and execution – delivers exponential returns.

Sources:

6.4
How To Turn A Cruise Ship
6.6
Research: Arc Browser Growth and User Base Report